Regular batch - You guys are good

Shoutout to everybody who made a file which ended up in my judging group. I'm replacing Silvuh and I wanted to let you know you were all doing pretty well.

I love you dragons.

This places LIVES.

but the question remains

which batch part o0o0o0o0

o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0

Are you one of those "easy" judges?

:l

yeah he is

It was my first time; I tried doing what I thought was right. I tried to judge by the way I saw the others do it from previous batches, but I still couldn't get around being super subjective about all this. AJ and Kayla were the first to realize it.

I was curious to see how your ratings compared to qqwref's and AJ's, and you were fairly consistent with their ratings to be honest. There were a few that they gave 4's but you gave a 5, but other than that, you weren't ever really out of the ballpark from them.

Reasoning for giving those grades though, I'm not sure how you compare. I didn't read into the notes, only looked at the ratings.

But I'm not complaining, you gave my file a 5 as well as qqwref did xD AJ helped me clean it up a bit though so hopefully you'll like this version better.

Can't really compare to qq cause he's well I'm not even gonna say it. And I'm not gonna bother getting into it cause I'm in no mood for debating anything with anyone.

IM SO FUCKING TIRED OF PEOPLE WANTING CONSISTENT RATING AMONGST JUDGING. WHAT THE FUCK IS THE POINT OF HAVING MORE THAN ONE JUDGE IF ALL THE JUDGES OPINIONS ARE SUPPOSE TO COINCIDE WITH EACH OTHER

STOP FUCKING BITCHING WHEN SHIT DOESNT GET THE SAME OR ALMOST THE SAME RATING BY ALL THE JUDGES, FUCK

Metro Controversy all over again

file of the batch :')

wc wrote:

IM SO FUCKING TIRED OF PEOPLE WANTING CONSISTENT RATING AMONGST JUDGING. WHAT THE FUCK IS THE POINT OF HAVING MORE THAN ONE JUDGE IF ALL THE JUDGES OPINIONS ARE SUPPOSE TO COINCIDE WITH EACH OTHER

STOP FUCKING BITCHING WHEN SHIT DOESNT GET THE SAME OR ALMOST THE SAME RATING BY ALL THE JUDGES, FUCK

The reason for consistent rating is to show how differing opinions compare. If multiple opinions come to the same conclusion, that's usually a positive, especially if one or more opinions are strong or extreme. Would you want a file that got two +'s and a ? in game?

Besides, this wasn't even the point I was making. I was trying to show Felix that, even though he believed himself to be subjective, the judges who were (for the most part (not talking about AJ)) objective, his ratings compared. I even stated that I didn't read why he gave those ratings to help disprove his subjectivity. I was attempting to boost morale. Apologies.

bad example, a file with two +'s and a ? wouldnt make it into the queue and would be further improved upon before anything

Midigami wrote:

Metro Controversy all over again

There was a controversy?