Batch Review Thread

I wonder what he thinks.... Hm.

also at the end, you say the ending stream shouldn't be there, but on 0.5x, you can hear that if defiantly fits (albeit with a couple extra layered in notes)

Remember that .5 is not 1.0. Just because it fits well on .5 doesn't mean it'll snuggly fie well on 1.0

Exactly. While every arrow might be perfectly in sync, if they go too fast to be pressed, it's just not fun at all. For instance, if your song only gets playable at 0.5x, I guess you should lower the difficulty.

bob bob, consider how the file plays at normal speed first - part of making simfiles is to sort out essential vs nonessential sounds and instruments to step

Erm, Carlos, what about that Classical Insanity.sm file you mentioned in your review? It's not in the list of files awaiting review and I sure as hell wouldn't step a song already in the FFR engine since like 2002. Unless this is just a dumb joke, I don't understand what happened here.

Also, thank you for your scores, it is very appreciated. Now, now, where can we hear more about this "climax theory"? ;D

look at your files and see which one has classical insanity.sm

Twister is lawl, wasn't being serious with it. Similar to when I stepped Slashmaid

Got me there, wc.

I forgot to rename it. This happened because before using ddream I didn't know how to create blank sm files apart from copying other sm's already existing.


The song's name should read "In Flux (5 Note Piano Prelude)"

Yeah what is the climax theory?

rofl sex pun

The climax theory is [I hope I get this relatively right] is pretty much like it is in books. There's a beginning, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution.

To apply it to a file, you'd start at some difficulty, play around with that, then progressively get harder or more exciting. If you are having a whole bunch of crap throughout, then there's no excitement. Especially if the song has a climax which is more exciting than the rest of the song, then you'd want that part to have more to it.

Hope I explained that kind of well. I wish I could think of a good file that shows the climax theory well but I haven't played today so I can't think of any off the top of my head.

That does make some sense but then the file wouldn't be so beginner friendly as I'd intended it... Kinda hard to apply that to a file that is mostly 8th notes with only 2 12th notes though. But I'll look at it to see if I can do something reasonable with it. (Referring to the chart for "Bells")

I'll check the out on my Animus... even though I think I layered pretty much all there was to layer =/

Even in easier files you can have climax theory. You don't have to go nuts and make it uber difficult to achieve it. It's just like a little extra umph at the end of a file.

what kayla said

emphasis to sound can be used to show climax AKA BOOMS get hands even though its only one sound being stepped

FEEL FREE TO SEND ME A MESSAGE THROUGH PM HERE OR FFR OR AIM(drtrantastic) MSN(whocares973@hotmail.com)SKYPE(who_cares973) IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS AS TO WHY REJECTED YOUR FILES

... Correct me if I'm wrong, Carlos, but isn't that the main reason why reviews exist?

His reviews were short and simple. I think what he's saying is if you'd like some more detail feel free to ask.

there is basic overview(which is what i do) and indepth deep down to the bone reviews which is on request. i dont find it fair for me to go in depth with every single file only to have most of the files never worked on again which is the case more often than not. AKA what kayla said

When I have the time I tend to write full, detailed reviews like I did with the first few in this batch. You'll know when I'm short on time if my reviews shrink a lot. In any case, anyone can PM me for more details.

Expect more reviews soon.

I have started mine, too.

I'd like to say they'll be done this week, but with me you never really know what'll come up.

Thanks Niala for the pat on the back about "Xkur Top Secrut!!!!!"!!!!!

Though I'm a bit perplex about one thing:

S: Fantastic
A: Accept

Review:

"-Absolutely fantastic. Those speedups were super cool. No real complaints." A

xP (yes, yes, there were PR mistakes. grumble mumble, one day I'll get an S from you!!!!!!)

I love how when I send in the file the first time, I get slammed for boring PR, then after the fix, I get slammed for "incorrect PR" because I made it different...not sure what to do here.

I don't even think "boring PR" makes sense. When it comes to PR, you either have good or bad PR, not "fun" or "boring" PR. Hopefully that'll make things a bit more linear.

Ask Carlos and AJ about the old version of the file. It had constant rolls because that's what the PR was; a whole bunch of up/down scales. Consistently playing rolls for a few minutes constitutes as "boring" PR, a lot of people can agree.

That can be constituted as a bad song to step. Some things are not meant to be.

Got it from an SM pack >.> sooooo....

Right then, the terminology is wrong. "Boring patterns" is more like it. I don't think I've got around to your song, so I'll let you know what I think when I get there.

Sorry if my first time judging is inadequate, but it's not as if I've done this before. I'll get better at it, and if you have any questions just PM me and I can elaborate on what I mean.

I didn't mean it to be rude Jeff. It was a mini rage because it's like >.> I change to people's liking then it's not right.

It's the matter of before, the song had too many repetitive patterns. So I got rid of them.

Niala wrote:

Sorry if my first time judging is inadequate, but it's not as if I've done this before. I'll get better at it, and if you have any questions just PM me and I can elaborate on what I mean.

Your judging is fine.

Nono, you're fine Niala.

:3 Sorry that was more diva-ish than I meant it. I'm aware that I'm new to this, so I'm gonna make mistakes, just ask and I can answer, though. Also, appreciate the warm support. n.n

Sara, if you were interested in what I meant by issues with the PR, it was that you had some spots where, for example, you'd start the highest note on the 4, and then continue with a roll pattern which would flow really well, and then next time around you'd start the roll on 3 and it would play weird because the pattern had just been done but they both started on a different arrow. This was more towards the middle of the song.

My biggest issue though was the flat difficulty, but I think adding a bit more layering could fix that up real nice.

Sorry again for the confusion, feel free to ask me questions about my reviews, though, I'm pretty open elaborating on my inconsistencies.

Judges are lazy!!

Updated, slowly but surely.

For those of you who sent fixes or newer files, I'll get to them later.

About carol of the bells

I took a pretty old school concept and added a new school spin on it. The i5h jumps that should be 4th are 8ths because they felt better as 8ths(QED theory). Should've been ovbious that I wasn't trying to add jumps to the 16th stream so not going to go into that. 16th stream does go to the guitar like you mentioned since its an up/down strum. If by mixing it up you mean adding jumps then nope. I left out the jumps for a reason and that reason should be pretty obvious. I'll check out the ghost notes though

Sorry Shiron, I sent the wrong file to the batch, the file ingame is the one that should have gotten judged, I'll send it to the email now. My bad~

Thanks for the tips on Bells I'll look at it again

I'll send the fixes on Purple Clouds and Bells later tomorrow I think. Hopefully rofl.

Bump

Halogen- wrote:

Piano Concerto 1 [Anti-Ares ~ Scorpion Fire] (iironic / ~Z~) [C]: There are a lot of technical errors in this chart that I actually would like to go through on another sitting; there's actually a lot of good in this file and your chart structure has an extreme amount of technicality that can make for a great high level file. I'm going to look at this in StepMania on another sitting to point out the things you should try to fix. Not a bad attempt at all.

Notes, please?

Thanks.

Sent fixes to The Awakening.

dead

no jinxing 0

Just was placed on hold due to adorable baby.

baby > 2010 batch

Always

Not dead just been super busy. Not only with baby but we moved to Jersey as well and my classes are ending.

Well hey if you guys need my help (Even if it's just sorting through folders or something) let me know